3-axis or 4-axis Machining, Which Is Better For You?

The effective implementation of CNC machining requires a thorough understanding of 3-axis and 4-axis milling.

It has become increasingly important to know the different capabilities of a CNC machine to produce cost-effective parts while providing high precision and accuracy.

But which one is best for you?

This blog will discuss the differences between 3-axis and 4-axis machining so you can decide on your production part needs.

What’s 3-axis Machining?

3-axis machining is a form of CNC (computer numerical control) machining that uses automated positioning in three axes to create complex parts with extremely high precision.

In 3-axis milling machines, the cutting tool can move in three directions—X, Y, and Z axes.

The flexibility of 3-axis CNC machining makes it an ideal choice for producing large numbers of finished goods as quickly as possible without sacrificing accuracy or quality.

Using toolpath programming to automate movement on these three axes, complex shapes, pockets, holes, and profiles can be precisely cut into any material on all 6 sides of a part at once with minimal operator intervention required during operation.

What’s 4-axis Machining?

4-axis machining refers to a CNC process that introduces an additional rotary (A) axis into traditional 3-axis operations.

The extra degree of freedom in the X, Y, Z, and A directions enables more complex parts with intricate features to be milled effectively and precisely than if it was just performed along three axes.

Instead of the cutting tool being limited only to linear motion (back and forth, left and right), this 4th dimension allows material removal on orbiting or curved surfaces with circular milling patterns.

In addition, this type of multiaxis machining offers greater flexibility for milling away at various sides of a given object throughout its entire compound shape without changing its position or setup – something traditional 3-axis cannot handle.

The added complexity also provides more efficiency through pocketing operations by automatically fitting moves such as index positions around a part’s four sides instead of forcing operators to reposition workpieces inside their machines over multiple cycles manually.

3-axis and 4-axis Comprehensive Comparison

Gain an in-depth understanding of the differences between 3-axis and 4-axis CNC machining by exploring the various factors such as the number of controlled axes, movement and machining flexibility, operating procedures, and time/precision involved.

Number of Controlled Axes

In 3-axis machining, three axes of movement are used to control the cutting tool: X (left/right), Y (front/back), and Z (up/down).

On the other hand, 4-axis machining uses the same three primary axes plus an additional axis for rotation (A-axis). With this extra axis, a four-sided mill can rotate around its own center point, allowing even more complex operations and greater precision.

It's not just rotational operations enabled by the fourth axis, either. Multi-sided objects can be milled from multiple angles or long extrusions.

Movement and Machining Flexibility

4-axis CNC machining offers enhanced movement and flexibility compared to 3-axis machines.

With an additional rotary axis (A or R), it enables intricate and precise operations, allowing independent movement along X, Y, Z, and the added axis.

This flexibility is beneficial for cutting multiple faces simultaneously at shifting angles, increasing efficiency in production cycles.

The fourth axis is also advantageous for industrial automation, ensuring consistency in the repeatability of production runs.

Accessing all four sides with one setup reduces setup time, leading to cost savings for manufacturers while maintaining high precision in complex milling operations.

Operating Procedures

3-axis machining involves manual positioning of each axis, while 4-axis CNC mills automatically move tools along three linear directions and an extra rotary A-Axis.

Moreover, 4-axis control demands less manual input, as operators only need to program their desired actions into the software without individually positioning multiple axes.

Time and Precision

Generally, parts machined with 3-axis CNC milling take longer than those machined with 4-axis since only three axes are actively controlled during production.

This requires additional machine tools or procedures to produce complex operations such as tapers or angled cuts that require simultaneous manipulation on two nonadjacent axes.

On the other hand, the 4-axis can do this in one setup while maintaining precision levels within tolerances due to quality enhancement systems like sensors monitoring speed control, accuracy, temperature changes, and tool conditions, including wear and breakage of bits throughout the whole process.

What’s right for you?

Choosing the right machining technique depends on factors like part shape, precision needs, and design complexity.

For planar profiles and simple drillings, 3-axis machining works, while 4-axis CNC offers flexibility, simultaneous control of multiple axes, and better precision for complex shapes, like angular cutouts on cylindrical components.

Consider both types based on part suitability and cost efficiency, especially if budget constraints exist.

FAQs

What are the Future Trends in Multi-Axis Machining?

Modern manufacturing increasingly favors multi-axis CNC machines over traditional 3-axis CNCs.

Using 4- or 5-axis systems, coupled with precise engineering tools, allows for efficient production of intricate part geometries.

By employing techniques like tilt-index rotation, these machines can handle complex cone shapes that were challenging with 3-axis technology.

The simultaneous control of up to five axes enhances precision, expands part complexity tolerances, and reduces production time and costs.

What is XYZ axis CNC?

The three-axis control system typically consists of the X, Y, and Z axes, which refer to left-right movements, up-down motions, and forward-backward actions, respectively.

As the machine moves along these axes, it can cut materials with greater precision into intricate shapes and designs according to a digital model or instructions from programming software.

Moreover, XYZ axis CNC machines have an integrated spindle head that rotates around each linear axis and allows axial rotation for simultaneous movement across all three dimensions if possible.

This enables control on multiple planes at different angles compared to traditional 2D CNCs with just two basic directional controls – forwards & backwards, right & left, and up & down.

How to Choose Between 3-axis and 4-axis CNC Machining?

Choose between 3-axis and 4-axis CNC machining based on the number of controlled axes and movement flexibility.

4-axis machines offer an extra rotational axis for versatile movement, allowing for more complex tasks.

However, operating procedures are slightly more intricate due to the additional axis, requiring expertise in CNC technology compared to standard 3-axis models.

Conclusion

When it comes to CNC machining, the choice of 3-axis, 4-axis, or 5-axis machining ultimately depends on the part geometry and desired level of precision and complexity.

Generally speaking, 3-axis machines are used for simpler parts, while 4-axis and 5-axis machines can produce more complex geometries with a higher degree of accuracy.

For manufacturing operations that need to cut all six sides of a part without manual repositioning effort, 4- or 5-axis milling may be preferable over 3-axis milling.

Additionally, they have better precision and require less time than conventional 3 axis thanks to their versatility in tool movement directions.

Ultimately, it is essential for companies looking to upgrade their machining capabilities beyond the basic 3-axis cutting to consider all factors, such as cost-effectiveness, before settling upon an ideal solution that best fits their specific requirements.

For higher-quality and cost-effective CNC milling services, contact us today！